Let's talk about the new Amazon series, 'Elle,' and its intriguing yet perplexing nature as a 'Legally Blonde' prequel. From my perspective, this show presents an interesting conundrum: is it a clever reboot of a beloved franchise, or a narrative mess that fails to honor its source material?
The Elle Enigma
'Elle' attempts to expand upon the world of Elle Woods, the iconic character from the original film. However, it introduces a major inconsistency by revealing that Elle spent her teenage years in Seattle, a stark contrast to the California girl we know and love. This twist feels like a creative misstep, especially when considering the character's established continuity.
A Franchise Reboot or Creative Misstep?
Viewing 'Elle' as a standalone series, it makes business sense. It's an amiable attempt to capitalize on the 'Legally Blonde' brand. But creatively, it falls short of the charm and wit of the original. The show highlights both the adaptability and limitations of the concept.
Elle's Journey: Clueless Meets Legally Blonde
The series introduces Elle as a high school junior in 1995, giving her a Cher Horowitz-like vibe from 'Clueless.' Her sheltered life in LA is upended when her family moves to Seattle. Here, her bubbly personality and fashion sense become a liability, making for an awkward cultural clash. The show's portrayal of Seattle feels stereotypical and cheesy, but its tongue-in-cheek tone and '90s nostalgia soundtrack add a layer of charm.
Flat Setting, Confusing Message
The issue lies in the show's premise and setting. Seattle is depicted as a haven for punky rebels, yet everyone seems to march to the same drum. This contradiction leaves Elle feeling out of place and scorned for her 'conformity.' It's an awkward message that evokes a defensive reactionary position, suggesting that rich, straight, feminine white women are the most oppressed.
Cast Performance and Ensemble Potential
Lexi Minetree delivers an uncanny performance, channeling Reese Witherspoon's Elle Woods with precision. Minetree's technical prowess and emotional likability make her a standout. The supporting cast, including Tom Everett Scott and June Diane Raphael, also shine. However, some characters, like Elle's crush Miles, feel one-dimensional, serving more as plot devices than unique personalities.
Easter Eggs: Delightful or Groan-worthy?
The series includes 'Legally Blonde' Easter eggs, ranging from delightful (Bruiser the chihuahua) to cringe-worthy ('Hey, Elle, have you ever considered becoming a lawyer one day?'). While these references are understandable, given the show's reliance on the original's legacy, they also highlight its struggle to find its own identity.
Final Thoughts
'Elle' is a fascinating yet flawed attempt to expand the 'Legally Blonde' universe. It showcases the challenges of creating a successful prequel while honoring the original. Personally, I think it has potential, but it needs to find its own voice and tone to truly succeed. What do you think? Could 'Elle' find its place in the sun, or is it doomed to live in the shadow of its predecessor?
